Tag: Jews of Bangladesh

There are still Jews in Bangladesh – or are there?

Are there still Jews in Bangladesh? There was a liberating military commander (General Jacob), there may be a few business people and expatriates, but these a community do not make, writes Shalva Weil (of the School of Education, Hebrew University of Jerusalem, and Visiting Scholar, Faculty of History, University of Cambridge)  in Asian Jewish Life:

The National Assembly (Parliament) building of Bangladesh, designed by Jewish architect Louis Khan of Philadelphia  and completed eight years after his death
The Jews in East Pakistan (before it became Bangladesh) were in no way numerous and kept a very low profile in this Muslim country. Apparently today, a few Jews still remain, but they are quite assimilated.
 There is no synagogue today in Bangladesh, although a few expatriates do meet up on the eve of the Jewish New Year and on the Day of Atonement. Getting a portrait of this elusive community requires patience, a few of the right contacts and quite a bit of ‘digging’. A posting on Trip Advisor by a tourist asking where the synagogue is in Dhaka for Yom Kippur received no serious response and a few months later, the blog was closed “due to inactivity”.
Another Jewish blogger shared that he went through a full orthodox conversion, is himself of mixed ancestry, his father being Yemenite Jewish and his mother Bangladeshi. Other people have written into the same blog saying they do business with Bangladesh, visit there and a few even reside there. As one person wrote: “The only Jews you will find in Bangladesh are those merchants with extensive business reasons to stay in Bangladesh.”
But liberating military commanders, the monuments of great architects, intrepid travelers and fortune seeking businessmen do not make a community. The question still remains, who are the Jews of Bangladesh? Joseph Edward of Ontario, Canada, explained the history of his family and their unique ties to the region. Joseph’s father Rahamim David Barook and his older brother Ezra Barook, were born in Calcutta, and moved to what was then East Pakistan. They adopted the surname Edward; his brother Ezra was known as Eddy Edward. Rahamim David Edward, Joseph’s father, married a Catholic of Portuguese descent. His uncle married a tribal king’s daughter from the Chittagong Hill Tracts, and she gave birth to a son. However, his wife died during childbirth and Joseph Edward’s uncle gave the baby up to a Muslim family for adoption. Edward has been in contact with cousins living in Arad and Beersheba, Israel. Other members of the family live in Sydney, Australia, in the UK and in Toronto, Canada.
Two other families of Jewish descent do in fact still live in Dhaka, but they have converted to Catholicism. Priscilla nee Jacob was married to Alfie D’Costa, who died some years back. Priscilla had her own private school in Dhaka. Her brother Henry also married locally and still resides in Dhaka as a Catholic. Likewise, there were two other Jewish brothers in East Pakistan, whom Joseph Edward knew: Enoch and Zebulon Daniels. Enoch lived in Chittagong and Zebulon lived in Dhaka. Their children now live in Canada and the UK.
While the Jews in West Bengal managed to create a full community, the Jews of East Bengal largely lived there for commercial reasons. They were never numerous. Nevertheless, documentation of the Jews of Asia and specifically Pakistan is incomplete without information on the Jews of East Pakistan, or what is today Bangladesh. The full story of this elusive community remains to be written.

General Jacob, Bangladesh war hero, dies (updated)

–>

 With thanks: Maurice and Shaul

Update: Sam Marshall,
an
industrialist and President of the
Indian Jewish Heritage Center
, attended General Jacob’s funeral, together with
some 700 others who gathered to pay their last respects. All three Chiefs of Staff,
 the Minister of Defence, the former President of India, ambassadors
and fellow officers ‘who recounted many anecdotes of Jack’s past history’, the
Gurkha regiment, and about 12 other regiments, were represented. Marshall, a friend of General
Jacob for the past 25 years, delivered a eulogy:

 Jack Jacob:’a straight arrow’

 “Here lies a man who has served his country
with distinction. 

 “A man who devoted his life to his beloved India
with dedication, commitment and integrity.

 “A man who spoke his mind fearlessly even
though it got him into trouble at times with the Politicians and his
superiors.  Jack did not care.  He was what you call a ‘straight
arrow’.

 “Many a time he would counsel or admonish
me.  We had an unspoken almost spiritual bond.

 “We shall miss you dearly Jack.  You
were a wonderful human, an inspiration to us all.  Recognized wherever –
Bharat India, Bangladesh, Israel and amongst your many friends worldwide.

 You were a unique human being.  You have
done enough dear friend. Now is the time to sleep.”

Here is Sam
Marshall’s description of the funeral:

“Jack’s body was placed on a Gun Carriage with full
Military honours traversing the streets of Delhi and ending up at the Military
Centre at ‘BRAR’ Square.

His body was put in full view and accorded the
highest honour which only Heads of State or Royalty would normally receive.

Israel Danny Carmon and the Military Attaché Zeev
Mivtzari were also in attendance and remarked that this was an extraordinary
felicitation and very gratifying for Israel and India-Israel relations.

“It was indeed a privilege for me to be an integral
part of the whole process with interviews, assisting the Rabbi, the Kaddish,
made one feel truly humble to have played even a small part – very emotional
the whole affair.

We can all be proud of the heritage we have of this
Legend who is no more.  I am in discussion with Israel at various levels
to see how we can perpetuate his Name and his Legacy.”

Retired Indian Army Lieutenant General JFR Jacob passed away this morningin his 93rd year. The descendant of Baghdadi Jews who came to India in the 18th century, he is best remembered for his role
in the 1971 Indo-Pakistan War, and the
liberation of Bangladesh, reports India Today.

Born
in Kolkata (then Calcutta) in 1923, Jack Farj Rafael Jacob grew up in a
conservative Baghdadi Jews household under the British rule. His family
had originally come from Iraq and settled in Bengal in the mid-18th
century.

Jacob did his schooling from Victoria School in Kurseong,
West Bengal. Living in the boarding school, he visited home only during
school holidays as a boy.

As a teenager, Jacob was strongly influenced by wartime poetry. In his interview to The Times of Israel, he said that his family had taken in a family of Jewish refugees from Hitler’s Europe.

Unmarried
and childless, Jacob wrote a moving open letter to the youth of Delhi
at 93, addressing them as his “sons and daughters”.

Read article in full

Indian PM pays tribute to General Jack Jacob (Times of Israel)


Jewish Chronicle obituary 

More about General Jacob

Bangladesh has almost no trace of Jews left

 Ezra Barook

Although the Jewish general, JFR Jacob, played a major part in winning Bangladesh’s battle for independence, the country has discouraged Jews from remaining there, wiping out remembrance of
almost everything Jewish, including the synagogue. Shalva Weil writes in The Jewish Chronicle:

A piece on Jews in Bangladesh may raise some eyebrows. Bangladesh is
officially a parliamentary democracy, but 90 per cent of the population
is Muslim. There are no diplomatic relations with Israel, and Bangladesh
has discouraged Jews from remaining there, wiping out remembrance of
almost everything Jewish, including the synagogue. Yet once it was
different, and East Pakistan – today Bangladesh – boasted a thriving, if
small, Jewish community.

The East Bengal Jewish community was established by Shalom Cohen
(1762-1836), the founder of the Calcutta (today Kolkata) Jewish
community in West Bengal, who migrated from Surat to India in 1798.

Cohen came to Dacca (today Dhaka) to trade in cloths, silks and
muslins, and established business with Jewish employees in the capital.
In 1817, Moses Duek, a businessman married to Cohen’s eldest daughter,
Lunah, left Calcutta to reside for five years in Dacca, during which
time he established a prayer hall there.

Throughout the 19th century and first part of the 20th, Baghdadi Jews
continued to run businesses in Dacca, but most resided in Calcutta.
They traded textiles, pearls and opium, on which they became rich.

At the time of Partition of Bengal and India in 1947, there were some
4,000 Jews in West Bengal, primarily in Calcutta but only about 135
Jews were actually residing in East Bengal. East Bengal later became
East Pakistan, a part of the new nation of Pakistan, but separated
geographically from it by 1,600 kilometers of Indian territory.

Ironically, a Jewish architect from Philadelphia, Louis Kahn,
designed the most important building in East Pakistan, the Jatiyo
Sangsad Bhaban, the National Assembly building. Ranked as the world’s
largest legislative complex, this National Assembly was begun in 1961
and was only completed in 1982, eight years after Kahn’s death.

In 1971, the Bangladesh Liberation War took place. Interestingly, it
was another famous Jew, Lieutenant General J F R Jacob, who liberated
East Pakistan during this war. General Jacob, as he is known, was
formerly governor of the Punjab and Goa; today he resides in New Delhi.
He was born into a Baghdadi Jewish family in Calcutta, and never hid his
Jewish ancestry.

On the contrary, when I first reached India in the
late 1970s, Lt General Jacob was an active member of the well-known New
Delhi prayer hall, the Judah Hyam Synagogue, which celebrated its 50th
anniversary in January 2007. He reached the highest ranks in India,
which traditionally promoted co-existence and lived in harmony with its
Indian Jewish minority. His finest hour was in 1971 when, as Chief of
Staff of the Indian Army’s Eastern Command, he defeated Pakistan during
the Indo-Pakistani War in two weeks, and successfully liberated East
Pakistan. As fighting raged, he flew to Dhaka and negotiated with
Pakistan’s military commander an unconditional surrender of 90,000
Pakistani soldiers to the Indian Army. This public surrender, enacted
under the auspices of the United Nations, is the only one in history.
East Pakistan then became the independent state of Bangladesh.

There is no synagogue today in Bangladesh, although a few expatriates
do meet up on the eve of the Jewish New Year and on the Day of
Atonement. A posting on Trip Advisor by a tourist asking where the
synagogue is in Dhaka for Yom Kippur received no serious response and a
few months later, the blog was closed by the Trip Advisor staff “due to
inactivity”. On a blog relating to the Jews of Bangladesh, one blogger
writing from Brooklyn, New York, told that he was of mixed ancestry, his
father being Yemenite Jewish and his mother Bangladeshi; he himself
went through a full Orthodox conversion. Other people have written into
the same blog saying they do business with Bangladesh, visit there, and a
few even stay for a while. As one person wrote: “The only Jews you will
find in Bangladesh are those merchants with extensive business reasons
to stay in Bangladesh.”

Joseph Edward of Ontario, Canada, wrote to me the history of his
family and gave me permission to quote him. Joseph was born in
Chittagong, Bangladesh, and moved to Canada in 1986. In Chittagong,
there is a Second World War British and Commonwealth cemetery, the War
Cemetery. There one can find the grave of an RAF sergeant from England
with the Star of David on it. Joseph Edward’s father, Rahamim David
Barook and his older brother Ezra Barook, were born in Calcutta, and
moved to what was then East Pakistan. They adopted the surname Edward;
his brother Ezra was known as Eddy Edward. Rahamim David Edward
(formerly Barook), Joseph’s father, worked in the shipping industry, and
married a Catholic of Portuguese descent, who was a school teacher. His
uncle married a tribal Chakma king’s daughter from the Chittagong Hill
Tracts. She died during childbirth and Joseph Edward’s uncle gave his
son up to a Muslim family for adoption.

Joseph Edward’s great-grandfather, Ezra Barook or Hacham Reuben
(pictured left), came from a distinguished Rabbinic family from
Baghdad; he was buried in the cemetery in Calcutta in 1900. In recent
years, Joseph Edward has been in contact with Jewish cousins living in
Arad and Beersheba, Israel. Other members of the family live in Sydney,
Australia, in the UK and in Toronto, Canada.

Read article in full

About

This website is dedicated to preserving the memory of the near-extinct Jewish communities, of the Middle East and North Africa, documenting the stories of the Jewish refugees and their current struggle for recognition and restitution.

Point of No Return

Jewish Refugees from Arab and Muslim Countries

One-stop blog on the Middle East's
forgotten Jewish refugees - updated daily.