Arab ‘normalisation’ initiative falls short of dialogue with Israelis

Update: See below for important NY Times report.

According to Jenni Frazer writing in Jewish Weekly,  a public ‘groundbreaking’ initiative bringing together Arabs who want normalisation with Israel has been held in London. However, no Israelis were present, because some of the delegates could have been subject to prosecution in their home countries for the “crime” of normalising relations. See my comment below.



The participants came from all over the Arab world, and were young and old, men and women, diplomats, media and arts personalities, often at odds with the leadership of their states but taking a nuanced and independent route to talking about the resolution of the Arab-Israel conflict.

Mohamed Dajani photographed at Auschwitz

 Some of the delegates, such as Mohammed Dajani, a Palestinian academic who shocked the Arab world by taking a group of his students to Auschwitz, were already well known to Israeli activists.

But many of the opinions were highly significant, not just because they are music to Jewish and Israeli ears, but because this is the first time that such declarations have been made in public and on the record.

 Taking place, by coincidence, on the anniversary of the late Egyptian president Anwar Sadat’s historic 1977 visit to Israel, the conference, warmly commended by US diplomat and long time Middle East peace negotiator Dennis Ross, produced some revelatory discussions and presentations. Not least were numerous personal stories about good relations with Jews, and a plea from several participants for Jews to return to Arab countries and work there for reconciliation.

Professor Dajani suggested that the stories of close interaction with Jews could be collected and published by the new Arab Council.

 Extremism and terrorism were deplored, and concern expressed about “brainwashing” of children in school and of students at university level; and, remarkably, from the clerics Hassen Chalghoumi, a condemnation of the “politicization” of Islam, and from Lebanon’s Saleh Hamed, a plea to Europe to crack down on the number of mosques in which imams were preaching hatred.

 In a video link from Washington D.C., Ambassador Ross told the participants that their deliberations “would have been wonderful if they had happened years ago,” but nevertheless he welcomed the initiative.

 He said, “You represent the voices who say enough. The more voices like yours who are prepared to speak out, the more you will build your voice [in talking] with Israel, and the more you will influence Israel’s leaders. You represent a ray of hope: it is a courageous endeavor, but also the right endeavor, and I am inspired by your example. You know you are on the right path.”

 
Read article in full

My comment: this initiative is welcome,  but falls short of ‘groundbreaking’ because it does not address the elephant in the room: the Arab world’s failure to engage directly with Israelis. Accounts of how well Jews and Arabs got on together and calls for Jews to return belong in the realm of fantasy: the Arab side needs to acknowledge that they need to talk to real Israelis, most of whom hail from Arab and Muslim countries. Oddly, Dennis Ross commends them for ‘building a voice in order to influence Israel’s leaders’  – what about the Arab world’s leaders?

David Halbfinger of  the New York Times reports: 


Boycotting
Israel and its people has only strengthened both, while doing great
harm to Arab countries, and not least to the Palestinians. For the sake
of the region, it is long past time to move forward to a post boycott
era.

 

That’s
where the Arab Council for Regional Integration aims to go. The council
formed this week in London and is made up of 32 civic actors from 15
Arab countries, including us. The council isn’t a government
organization—members include heads of NGOs, prominent media figures,
Muslim clerics, and even musicians. The only political figures who
attended were a former Kuwaiti information minister and an Egyptian
legislator who also heads a political party there. Regardless of
profession, those gathered espoused a spirit of partnership that knows
no borders and repudiates the culture of exclusion and demonization that
has wreaked havoc across the Arab world. First on our list is the
generations-old boycott of Israel and Israelis.

 

The
boycott evolved in stages. In the mid-20th century, Arab elites enacted
exclusionary policies against 900,000 Jews indigenous to Arab lands,
culminating in their mass dispossession and forced migration. In the
1940s, the internal crackdown developed into an intergovernmental Arab
effort to target the young country to which most of these Jews
fled—Israel—through political, cultural and economic isolation. The goal
was to uproot them and their European Jewish brethren from the area.
Next came a ban on all civil engagement with Israelis, even and
especially in countries nominally at peace with Israel.

 

The
latest iteration is driven largely by foreigners: The Boycott,
Divestment and Sanctions movement aims to drive a wedge between Israelis
and their global partners. Each boycott has failed to defeat Israelis.
Instead, the economic pressure inspired innovative responses that
invigorated their economy and society.

 

But
let us count the ways the boycotts have harmed Arab societies. They
lost the economic benefits of forming partnerships with Israelis. Trade
could provide desalination technology for parched Yemen or more
investment in Jordan where unemployment rates are overwhelming. The
exclusionary movement impeded Arabs from resolving tensions between
Israelis and Palestinians. Hard-line “resistance” factions such as Hamas
have enjoyed support from numerous powers, but those Palestinians
striving justly and peacefully to build institutions for a future state
can hardly find Arab partners. Nor have they been able to trade or form
contracts with Israelis—which would have empowered them economically,
and given them some leverage to move the area toward peace.

 

Worse
still, the regional boycott of Israel became a template for excluding
and marginalizing opposition in the Arab world. Ethnic and sectarian
divisions hardened, hastening the disintegration of Syria, Iraq, Libya
and Yemen.

 

To
rebuild the region, we must break with this tragic history. Much of the
media and many of the political institutions in the Arab world are
waging a rhetorical war against Israel’s legitimacy in the public’s
mind. 

New York Times article 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

About

This website is dedicated to preserving the memory of the near-extinct Jewish communities, of the Middle East and North Africa, documenting the stories of the Jewish refugees and their current struggle for recognition and restitution.

Point of No Return

Jewish Refugees from Arab and Muslim Countries

One-stop blog on the Middle East's
forgotten Jewish refugees - updated daily.