Does the Mizrahi campaign delegitimise Ashkenazim?

Where does the campaign for Mizrahi rights leave Ashkenazi Jews? Lyn Julius, writing in the Times of Israel, reassures them: Jews are all one people, whose two halves have been reunited.

A battle is currently raging to rebut the calumny in the court of
world opinion that ‘Israel is a ‘white settler’ state. Leftist groups in
the US have recently gone further, and tarred all Jews – not just
Zionists in Palestine – with the ‘white’ brush.  The postcolonial orthodoxy is that Palestinian ‘people of color’ are
the true natives; Jews are foreign interlopers who have ‘stolen’ their
land.

My organisation, Harif, the UK Association of Jews from the Middle East and North Africa,
has been playing its part in trying to dispel these myths. Harif was
founded to raise awareness of the post-war destruction and dispossession
of ancient Jewish communities in the Arab and Muslim world and their
transplantation, in large part, to Israel. But does making the case for
Sephardi/Mizrahi Jews necessarily detract from the right of Ashkenazi
Jews to self-determine in Israel? Does the fact that our sister
organisation JIMENA has

 an ‘I’ in its name that stands for Indigenous – imply that non Sephardim/Mizrahim are not indigenous?
The purpose of groups such as Harif and JIMENA is to draw special
attention to a sector of the world Jewish population whose existence is
routinely denied or ignored. The Mizrahim never left the ‘Arab’ world –
they merely moved from one corner of the region to another. It is
essential emphasize their indigeneity vis-a-vis the Arabs, who
arrived in the greater Middle East and North Africa 1,000 years after
the Jews. Native Jews, who now happen to comprise the majority of the
Jews of Israel, also have a specific quarrel with Arab and Muslim
states: these regimes need to be called to account for ‘ethnically
cleansing’ their Jews. Our job is to advocate for Mizrahi rights to
justice – recognition and redress. The plight of Middle Eastern Jews is
also essential to understanding the ongoing Arab and Muslim conflict
with Israel and the persecution of minorities.

There is another important goal: to vindicate the legitimacy of the
sovereign state of Israel in the modern Middle East. As an aboriginal
people of the Middle East the Jews of the region have no less a right to
a state of their own in their ancestral homeland. In the words of the
great Tunisian-Jewish writer Albert Memmi:’if one were to base oneself
on this legitimacy and not on force and numbers, then we have the same
rights to our share of these lands – neither more nor less – than the
Arab Muslims.’

To campaign for Mizrahi rights is not to delegitimize Ashkenazi Jews.
Jews from East and West form one Middle Eastern people, whose two
halves have become reunited in their ancestral homeland.

A montage of ‘white’ US Ashkenazi celebrities (Dani I. Behan)

Jews from the West were often treated as swarthy aliens during their
2,000-year peregrinations in Europe, and have closer genetic links with
their Sephardi and Mizrahi brethren than they do with non-Jewish
Europeans. Nowadays it is fashionable to smear Ashkenazi Jews as Khazar
converts with no roots in the Middle East. Replacement theology declares
Jesus to be a Palestinian and the Palestinian Arabs the new Jews.

It was not always thus. Only 75 years ago, millions of Jews became
non-white sub-human victims of the Nazi genocide. They had been despised
as exotic, but unwanted, outsiders in Europe. As the Israeli novelist
Amos Oz wrote:’When my father was a little boy in Poland, the streets of
Europe were covered with graffiti,”Jews go back to Palestine’, or
sometimes worse:’Dirty Yids, piss off to Palestine’. When my father
revisited Europe fifty years later, the walls were covered with new
graffiti,’Jews get out of Palestine.’

A disturbing new trend in the West sees Jews no longer as an
oppressed minority, but part of the white establishment, identified with
wealth, success and power.

For all the reasons listed in Dani Behan’s excellent article, Ashkenazim are part of the nation of Israel. Ashkenazi, Sephardi, Mizrahi are mere geographic terms.

Now that the pernicious vogue for describing all Jews as ‘white’ is
spreading in leftist circles in the US, it is important for all Jews to
show our credentials as ‘people of color’, no matter how silly and
reductive this label is.

We are all one people, with a common origin and a common destiny.

Read article in full

2 Comments

  • I think this article was unnecessary. Why would telling the story of mizrahim delegitimize ashkenazim or any other group of jews? No more than telling the story of black americans delegitimze white americans or any other group in the US.

    Footnote: whether jews are white or not depends if one considers Semites as white.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

About

This website is dedicated to preserving the memory of the near-extinct Jewish communities, of the Middle East and North Africa, documenting the stories of the Jewish refugees and their current struggle for recognition and restitution.

Point of No Return

Jewish Refugees from Arab and Muslim Countries

One-stop blog on the Middle East's
forgotten Jewish refugees - updated daily.