New paradigm sees Israel as a haven from Sunni persecution

For most of the 20th century Zionism meant saving the Jews of Europe in a revived Jewish homeland. This led to the misconception, spread by Palestinian propaganda, that Israel is an alien, colonialist state. Today, however, a new paradigm is emerging of Israel as a Middle Eastern nation in need of a haven from Sunni Muslim persecution, argues Edward Retting in Fathom.  Rettig is broadly right, but this new political paradigm did not emerge organically, but  after pressure from the US Congressand  a decade of hard lobbying for recognition and justice for the victims of Arab and Muslim antisemitism  by MKs and organisations in Israel representing Jews from Arab countries.

Then, with the rise of the first Likud government in 1977, a new
political elite revised the classic Zionist paradigm. Oddly, considering
its profound influence on the conflict, this revision – which involves
an essential change in how most Israeli Jews now see the conflict – has
drawn little international discussion. At the heart of the revision is
the growing awareness of the experience of ethnic oppression of
the Jews in the Muslim world and the growing influence of the
ethnically cleansed Jews of the Muslim world and their descendants in
Israeli society, culture and politics. Today, almost three-quarters of
the Jewish population is Israel-born, and more and more young Jewish
Israelis ‘intermarry’ across the Eastern-Western Jewish divide, ensuring
that a growing percentage, probably more than a majority, now trace at
least part of their origins to the wider Muslim-dominated region.

 Ed Rettig: colonialist paradigm turned upside down

Simply put, Israel has become much more attuned to its neighborhood
as it has incorporated these migrants and their descendants. Much of the
population that absorbed these migrants consisted of Holocaust
survivors and other refugees from Europe, which contributed indirectly
to the widespread but shallow anti-Zionist idea that ‘Europeans’ invaded
Palestine. But today, at the age of 70, Israel is much less
Europe-centered and not only in music, food, literature, popular
culture, and so on but also in politics and foreign policy.

This emergent Israeli paradigm is also the result of regional
developments since the 1940s. From the Atlantic coast of North Africa,
eastward to the Shiite provinces of the Persian Gulf, a group of
countries form one of the great contemporary civilisations. Sunni Muslim
Arabs overwhelmingly dominate the region demographically and
politically. Unfortunately, Sunni Muslim Arab society faces a deep
crisis as it struggles to reconcile modernity with its traditional
values and culture, a predicament that lies beyond the bounds of this
paper. A common symptom of the crisis is that virtually all of the
non-Sunni, or non-Arab, or non-Muslim populations in the region – Copts,
Maronites, Assyrians, Jews, Kurds, Yazidis, Shiites, and so forth –
suffer severely. Today, the situation of these minorities provides an
essential framework in which one can reinterpret Arab behavior in 1948.
We might call this new understanding the ‘hegemonic majority paradigm’.
It can shape our perception of events such as the Syrian civil war
(where the pro-Assad coalition is glued together by fear of majority
Sunni ascendancy), the rise of ISIS (an expression of Sunni political
extremism), and, of course, the current dynamics between Israelis and
Palestinians (who are ethno-religiously overwhelmingly Sunni Muslim

This emerging Jewish Israeli paradigm turns many ‘anti-colonialist’
assumptions upside down. Of all the minorities in the region, only the
Jews have prospered since the end of World War Two. We did this despite
the murder of large numbers of us, the seizure or abandonment of much of
our property, the waging of wars against us, the ongoing reverberations
of the Holocaust, and the anti-Israel political clout of the Arab
peoples and the Soviet Bloc. The new paradigm says that what allowed for
this success was the fact of withdrawal (sometimes willingly, often
through outright expulsion), from the Sunni Muslim Arab hegemonically
dominated areas, to congregate with other Jews from other parts of the
world in the land of our shared history.

Read article in full

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This website is dedicated to preserving the memory of the near-extinct Jewish communities, of the Middle East and North Africa, documenting the stories of the Jewish refugees and their current struggle for recognition and restitution.

Point of No Return

Jewish Refugees from Arab and Muslim Countries

One-stop blog on the Middle East's
forgotten Jewish refugees - updated daily.