From the Nile to Lake Geneva, the ‘dhimmi’ to Eurabia

Gisele Littman had always wanted to write a
novel. For years, the potential characters danced around inside her
head. Instead, turbulent events in her life threw her in quite a
different direction.  Lyn Julius reviews her autobiography in the Times of Israel:

Born in Cairo, she was forced to flee Egypt with
her family after Nasser’s mass expulsion of Jews in 1956. As a result,
she immersed herself in politics and dedicated her writing talents to
the study of the volatile relationship between Jews and Muslims. Her
best-known work is ‘The Dhimmi’: an account of the subjugated status of defeated non-Muslims as a by-product of jihad. She
has also championed the cause of Middle Eastern Christians. More
recently, she coined the term Eurabia for the anti-Zionist strategic
‘alliance’ between the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation and the
European Community. 

Gisele and David met in London as students and
fell in love. They were an unlikely couple – she the francophone, shy,
diminutive and destitute Jewish refugee from Egypt, he the tall,
confident, patrician product of a British public school and scion of a
wealthy family.

Gisele and David Littman settled near Lake Geneva and forged a remarkable partnership during his lifetime, which ended in 2012.

Wading through the mountains of documents and
letters which David kept scattered in the office of their Swiss home,
Gisele Littman has now written her political autobiography (in French).

David meticulously checked her work and
translated her books into English. He had a prodigious memory for facts,
answered the ‘phone for her and made all her arrangements. No
manuscript could go to a publisher until he had been through it with a
fine toothcomb. David shielded her from hostile critics. Sparks did fly
between these two strong characters, but her book is in many ways, an
elegant, and absorbing, tribute to David: ‘L’amour est plus fort que la mort.’

and Gisele Littman with their baby daughter Diana. 

The family spent
three months in Morocco working 

on ‘Operation Mural’ in 1961.

It is a measure of her courage, so soon after
she had fled another Arab country, that Bat Ye’or ( a pseudonym meaning
‘Daughter of the Nile’, adopted by Gisele for security reasons)
consented to accompany her husband to Morocco in 1961. In a covert
Mossad operation posing as an Anglican gentleman, David risked his life
to help smuggle out over 500 Jewish children to Israel via Switzerland
in ‘Operation Mural’. (He bitterly refused to visit Israel until his
work had been officially recognised). In the 1970s, the couple were
among the founders of the World Organisation of Jews from Arab
Countries. David was a lifelong human rights activist, a lobbyist at the
United Nations and a historian.

They had a circle of academic admirers and
like-minded friends – Paul Fenton, Robert Wistrich, Leon Poliakov. But
Bat Yeor’s work set on her on a collision course with the doyens of the
politically-correct, the interfaith mavens and the revisionists, who
accused her of everything from insanity to feeding the Islamophobia of
the far-right. In one memorable vignette, she found herself seated at a
Geneva dinner party next to Professor George Steiner, a man with
fashionable pro-Palestinian views. She told him that Jews in the Maghreb
could not leave their quarters with their shoes on. ” I don’t believe a
word you say,” he shot back. Between the cheese and the dessert, a
fierce argument erupted between George Steiner and David Littman, always
fearlessly outspoken in defence of his wife. It ended with Steiner
storming out of the dinner party.

Personal tragedy cast a shadow over David and
Gisele’s life – their daughter Diana was born mentally handicapped and
their son Daniel committed suicide. Nevertheless, Bat Ye’or soldiered on
in her mission. She will go down in history as one of the major
contributors to the understanding of political Islam and its treatment
of religious minorities. She may never get to write her novel. Fiction’s
loss is scholarship’s gain.

‘Autobiographie Politique: De la découverte du dhimmi à Eurabia’ by Bat Ye’or: ( 24 Euros, Les Provinciales, 2017)

Read article in full

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This website is dedicated to preserving the memory of the near-extinct Jewish communities, of the Middle East and North Africa, documenting the stories of the Jewish refugees and their current struggle for recognition and restitution.

Point of No Return

Jewish Refugees from Arab and Muslim Countries

One-stop blog on the Middle East's
forgotten Jewish refugees - updated daily.