Mayor calls Jewish refugee campaign ‘insulting’

Opposition to the campaign by minister Gila Gamliel to document the stories of 850,000 Jews expelled from Arab lands came from an unlikely quarter yesterday:the mayor of the Israeli town of Ness Ziona. That Yossi Shabo’s family came to Israel 67 years ago because they were Zionists is not in question. More worrying, is that Shabo showed his ignorance of the ‘push factors’ his family suffered in their native Egypt. Yediot Aharonot reports: 

  Mayor Yossi Shabo clashed with Minister Gila Gamliel (photo: Mark Israel Sellem)

The Mayor of Ness Ziona, Yossi Shabo, today (Wednesday) came out against the flagship project of Minister Gila Gamliel to document the
heritage of Jewish communities in Arab countries and Iran, claiming:
“Arab countries did not expel us, we  came voluntarily.”


Recently the Minister for Social Equality has been running a campaign on the expulsion of Jews from Arab countries. It aims to point out the injustice
directed against the Jews in their home countries.
But the mayor, a member of the Likud Central Committee who immigrated to Israel from Egypt 67 years ago, the issue is not yet settled. In a letter sent to Gamliel, protesting the campaign, he called it “insulting”.
According to him, it “implies that Jews from Arab countries wanted to live
in exile in their own countries, and only expulsion brought them to immigrate to Israel. I strongly protest this distortion of history.”


When his family emigrated to Israel, his father paid for them to travel to Europe and from there they arrived in Israel. 

“A little effort on your part would clarify that the State of
Israel through its agents paid a lot of money to the leaders of the Arab
countries to allow the immigration of Jews to Israel. The immigration of
Moroccan Jews was only made possible thanks to the involvement of the Mossad and the Jewish Agency. In light of this, I ask whence came the
theory of expulsion? “


Shabo ended his letter demanding:”in the name of my family and like all Jews
from Arab lands, I challenge you to correct the mistake, stop the
campaign and announce publicly that Jews in Arab countries left  out
of Zionist motives and were not expelled.”


The national plan for documenting the heritage of Jewish communities in the
Arab countries and Iran has been approved by the government at a cost of 10
million shekels.

The joint venture will be run by the Government Press Office, together
with the Ministry for Social Equality led by Gamliel. They will collect 
testimonies from the public.
A memorial day to mark the departure and expulsion of Jews from the Arab lands and Iran has been commemorated in Israel since 2014.


The Ministry for Social Equality commented: ” The Law for a Day to mark the departure
and expulsion of Jews from Arab countries and Iran was passed back in
2014, while the office  responsible for its implementation is the Ministry
for Social Equality. But there is no contradiction that all who immigrated to Israel from
Arab countries and Iran, between those who were driven out  and those who came
to Israel from Zionism and by virtue of being  Jews. 

The lack of
knowledge of the mayor of Ness Ziona about the many families who were
expelled from Arab countries after the establishment of the state, only
intensifies the need to fill in  the missing part of
the story of the Jews from Arab countries and Iran and bring it to public
attention. “


Levana Zamir, chairman of the umbrella organization of Jews from Arab
and Muslim countries, said in response: “we wonder how one man
allows himself to make statements on behalf of 850,000 Jews from
Arab countries, some of whom were expelled and some of whom fled for
their lives.
To speak these words comes only from serious ignorance of what really happened. The mayor’s remarks are outrageous to hundreds of thousands of Israelis from Arab countries. How can he claim that  Oriental Jews were not expelled at all when I myself was banished ?” 


Zamir added: “with all due respect, I know  Ness Ziona elected the
and is proud of it, but  the story does not represent all
Jews of Egypt, let alone a million Jews from Arab countries and Iran. I
do not understand how he came out against minister
Gamliel. She is the first minister in Israel’s history who decided to enact the Memorial Day Law, and to take action to correct the
ignorance regarding the story of the Mizrahi Jews. “

Read article in full (Hebrew) 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This website is dedicated to preserving the memory of the near-extinct Jewish communities, of the Middle East and North Africa, documenting the stories of the Jewish refugees and their current struggle for recognition and restitution.

Point of No Return

Jewish Refugees from Arab and Muslim Countries

One-stop blog on the Middle East's
forgotten Jewish refugees - updated daily.