Why the Afghan community is now defunct

Beth Koplik has  published a book on the history of Jews in Afghanistan in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries (especially from
1839 to 1952). This  once flourishing community  is now defunct. It struggled to recover from successive calamities (Mongol invasion, forced
conversion of Jews to Islam in Mashad). interview by Nathan Weinstock in Information Juive: 

Sara Beth Koplik

Jews frequently had to face difficult times and  as a
religious minority, they became the target of persecution.


minority was distinguished by unusual family structure patterns,
resulting from trade requirements with very remote areas: while men
undertook long journeys, women remained at home (particularly in Herat
and Kabul).

An accumulation of events in early 1930 led  to the gradual disappearance of the Jewish community. The
influx of large numbers of refugees, including from Bukhara – a consequence
of the quasi-Stalinist policy of genocide – prompted the Afghan
government to impose on the local Jewish population discriminatory laws
forbidding them to engage in commerce or travel outside major urban
Hence their  brutal impoverishment, aggravated by an economic policy focused on
development projects based on a monopoly system favouring the majority Pashtun.

Zevulum Simantov, the last Jew of Afghanistan, saying his prayers (Photo: Reuters)

the agreements concluded by Kabul with the Third Reich, under the
leadership of ‘Abd al-Majid Khan Zabuli, would allow Nazi Germany to
exert some influence on certain aspects of Afghan policy, especially in
the economic field.


After the Second World War, the Afghan economy collapsed and the region fell prey to starvation. The establishment of the State of Israel  was lived by the Jewish
community as the fulfillment of biblical prophecy and most of its
members left when they were finally allowed to emigrate.


The numerical strength of the community  increased due to the flight of Jews of Mashhad after their  (1839) forced mass conversion. In 1856, the whole Jewish community of Herat was forced to join the Persian army in its march to Mashhad, where its members  remained imprisoned for several years. Many of them died as a result of prison conditions.

At the end of the nineteenth century, they were exposed to a series of pogroms, including the massacre of eleven rabbis in Maimana. The early years of the twentieth century ushered in a best time for the community, but it was hit by new problems  from the early 1930s, forcing all Jews residing in the north to live either in Kabul either in Herat.

Bukharan refugees were locked in an old caravanserai and forbidden to engage in any work. The community was overwhelmed by the many restrictions of all kinds imposed upon it, which eventually triggered a refugee crisis: the Jews fled from Afghanistan to India, including Peshawar and Mumbai.

Read article in full (French) 

Doctoral thesis by Sara-Beth Koplik (PDF)


  • Georges Bensoussan agrees that in the late 19th century, the worst persecution of Jews was in Morocco and Iran [then still called Persia]

  • According the Bernard Lewis's book "Jews of Islam", the persecution of Jews since the advent of Islam was worst in all Muslim countries, with the exception of the Ottoman empire. Since the medieval times the worst conditions were in Morocco and Iran which included most of Afghanistan under the Safavids dynasty which came about after the devastating destruction of Sasanian empire during the 7th century Muslim conquest.

    The Muslim imperial conquest of Iran and Afghanistan came before the conquest of North Africa and subsequently Spain.

    Iran, Afghanistan and Morocco, according to Lewis, have remain relatively insular from the outside world influences for quite sometimes, thus creating one of the most virulent brand of anti-Jewish attitude and feelings.

  • can they blame the demise of this community on Zionism? On Netanyahu? [the usual scapegoat for everything according to Haaretz]. Things started getting bad for this community in the early 1930s. No State of Israel at that time.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This website is dedicated to preserving the memory of the near-extinct Jewish communities, of the Middle East and North Africa, documenting the stories of the Jewish refugees and their current struggle for recognition and restitution.

Point of No Return

Jewish Refugees from Arab and Muslim Countries

One-stop blog on the Middle East's
forgotten Jewish refugees - updated daily.