Rebutting Hamas’s Mizrahi narrative

 CNN’s Wolf Blitzer challenges Hamas’s spokesman Osama Hamdan

Enjoying greater media exposure during the Gaza war,  Hamas has been busy spreading the disinformation that the Muslim world welcomed Jews as ‘normal’ citizens before the establishment of Israel. JIMENA, the US organisation representing Jewish refugees from Arab lands, has been equally busy countering the lie. Article in Digital Journal: 

Amidst the flurry of international media surrounding the
Israeli-Palestinian conflict since Operation Protective Edge, one
crucial voice continues to be co-opted and silenced: that of indigenous
Mizrahi Jewish refugees from the Middle East and North Africa.

In an August 6, 2014 interview on CNN’s “The Situation Room” with Wolf Blitzer Hamas spokesman Osama Hamdan was questioned regarding his accusations
that Jews “slaughter Christians in order to mix their blood in their
holy matzoh.” In response, Hamdan denied the Anti-Semitism in Arab
countries, by painting a picture of Islamic societies as pluralistic and
accepting of Jews: “The Jews lived in the Arab region and among the
Muslims as normal citizens. When the Jews were kicked from Europe in the
mid-ages, they came to live in peace in our countries, and they were
accepted.” JIMENA President and Libyan native, Gina Bublil-Waldman
counters by noting that, “Jews have had a continuous presence in the
Middle East for over 2,500 years – an entire millennium before the
advent of Islam. Under Muslim rule, many Jewish communities in the Arab
world were relegated to a subservient, second-class “dhimmi” status.”

Hamdan is only the most recent to make this claim. Dr. Mousa Abu Marzook, then Deputy Head of Hamas’ political bureau, stated in an August 25, 2008 interview with IslamOnline:
“The Jews who were living under the Islamic rule were the happiest on
earth…Jews lived freely and ran prosperous businesses in Egypt and
Baghdad, and the markets of Baghdad are evidences of what the Jews
owned. Jews did not face any persecution or mistreatment.”

Hamas also refuses to recognize Mizrahi refugees, instead blaming them for their own exile and the plight of the Palestinians. In a September 22, 2012 public statement published by Ma’an News Agency,
Hamas spokesman Sami Abu Zuhri condemned the first UN conference on
Jewish refugees from Arab countries, held in New York in 2012, claiming
that “those Jews are criminals rather than refugees… They were actually
responsible for the displacement of the Palestinian people after they
secretly migrated from Arab countries to Palestine before they expelled
the Palestinians from their lands to build a Jewish state at their

As a leading representative voice of Jewish refugees from Arab countries, JIMENA: Jews Indigenous to the Middle East & North Africa
aims to achieve universal recognition of the Mizrahi refugee experience
by collecting and sharing the personal and communal eye-witness
testimonies of some of the 850,000 Jews who fled Anti-Semitic
persecution in the Arab world. Legal experts assert that the UN Agency
for refugees (UNHCR) recognized Jews fleeing Arab countries as bona fide
refugees. UN Resolution 242 which was unanimously adopted by the UN
Security Council officially recognized Jewish refugees from Arab

In a JIMENA testimony, Iraqi-born author Emil Murad describes the
long history of Anti-Semitism in Iraq: “From l930 all Iraqi governments
systematically suppressed any sign of Jewish or national consciousness
on the part of the Iraqi Jews…study of Jewish history was forbidden,
restrictions were imposed on relations with Jews abroad and Zionism was
considered to be treason.” In 1941, these actions culminated in the
massacre known as the Farhud: “They began dragging Jews out of buses and
murdering them in the road. Wild crowds and defeated soldiers who had
returned with their weapons to the city, saw the pogrom as a celebration
and a sort of amusement. The Jewish Quarter in the city centre became a
battlefield, with looting, robbery, and rape…The pogrom inflicted
mortal wounds on the Jewish community.”

JIMENA President Gina Bublil-Waldman recalls the danger to Jews in
Arab countries. “We were denied the most basic human and civil rights,
such as the right to become citizens, the right to vote, the right to
hold public office, or hold government jobs.” Waldman remembers the
pogroms in 1945 in her hometown of Tripoli, Libya: “Libyan Arabs looted
and burned Jewish homes and killed Jews. They dragged my neighbors and
relatives out on the streets and slaughtered them… Nine synagogues –
four of them in Tripoli – were burned to the ground, and 35 Torah
scrolls were destroyed.”

Mrs. Bublil-Waldman relates to ethnic and religious persecution in
Muslim countries today: “Mizrahi refugees can empathize and serve as
great allies to minorities from Arab countries. Honoring Mizrahi
history is key to understanding the suffering of Yezidis, Christians and
other oppressed groups, including Palestinian refugees, in the Middle

Read article in full:

One Comment

  • Two things: 1) CNN is as least as antisemitic as the BBC and 2) Wolf Blitzer is a tired sad old pathetic loser who lets anyone he 'interviews' about anything at all say whatever they like unchallenged.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This website is dedicated to preserving the memory of the near-extinct Jewish communities, of the Middle East and North Africa, documenting the stories of the Jewish refugees and their current struggle for recognition and restitution.

Point of No Return

Jewish Refugees from Arab and Muslim Countries

One-stop blog on the Middle East's
forgotten Jewish refugees - updated daily.