For Jews in France, ‘plus ca change’

 History is repeating itself for Jews in France, most of whom are descended from refugees from the Arab world. Traumatised by anti-Jewish riots, they are moving on for the second time in a generation, writes Lyn Julius in the Jerusalem Post:

Pro-Palestinian demonstrators shout ‘Death to the Jews’ at the 13 July Paris riot

The Jews of France are reeling. It’s
been a month that they would rather forget. Although all European Jewish
communities have been affected, the French community has, since the
outbreak of the Gaza war, seen a larger spike in violence than most.
Eight synagogues were attacked in a week. 

Jews in France no longer feel secure. Four times as many Jews as last year are leaving the country to move to Israel. Newsweek‘s lead story is  “Exodus: they’re fleeing once again”.

Antisemitic attacks have been on the rise for some time, culminating in
the murders of Sebastien Selam and  Ilan Halimi ; the Toulouse massacre
of three Jewish children and a rabbi; the gunning down of four people at
the Brussels Jewish museum by a French jihadi returning from Syria. All
these atrocities have shaken the 500,000-strong community to the core.
They have been taking their children out of public schools, moving to
‘safer’ areas of Paris, and choosing more Jew-friendly universities.

On 13 July 2014, Jews narrowly escaped a pogrom as an angry mob of
pro-Palestinian supporters funnelled down the rue de la Roquette in
Paris.  The JDL (Jewish Defence League)  improvised a line of defence
until police reinforcements arrived. Some mediaaccused
the vigilantes of provoking the violence, but their actions probably
saved  Jewish worshippers, barricaded inside the synagogue, from being

A week later, a  rampaging mob of 400 threw firebombs at a synagogue, a pharmacy and a kosher butcher in Sarcelles – a suburb of Paris where North African Jews and Muslims live cheek by jowl.

But  French Jews, who mostly hail from Algeria, Morocco, Tunisia and Egypt, are also experiencing a sense of deja-vu.  Bernard Abouaf, a journalist of Tunisian-Jewish descent who witnessed the Rue de la Roquette riot,
wrote on his Facebook page that the whole scene looked like a
re-enactment of the storming and torching of the Great Synagogue in
Tunis during the Six-Day War in 1967: a traumatic event that accelerated
the flight of Tunisian Jews to France or to Israel.

“What I have seen today,” he remarked, “is Arab hatred against Jews.
Pure hatred. Right in the middle of Paris. Don’t try to ‘explain’ or
‘understand’, it was hatred, period.”

Aurelie A. spoke to her father about the assault on La Roquette. ” I asked him if he had ever seen any such clashes,” she wrote in an article in the Tablet.

He answered, “yes…. In Algeria, before leaving it all behind… He added: but we were in Algeria, here we’re in metropolitan France!!”

In truth, long before Jews in Arab countries became hostages to the
conflict and bore the brunt of Arab frustration and anger over
Palestine, Jews were victims of anti-Jewish riots and massacres.

Take the Constantine pogrom, 80 years ago this week.

Jealousy and resentment of the Jews had been building among the Muslim masses of Algeria since the passing of the 1870 Decret Cremieux, which gave Jews French citizenship.

It all started on 3 August 1934 with a brawl involving a Jewish drunk
and a small group of Muslims. The Jew, a soldier, was accused of
urinating inside the famous Constantine mosque of Sidi Lakhdar. The
Muslims headed for the Jewish quarter of the town, attacking Jewish
passers-by and wrecking shopfronts. Some Jews defended themselves.  
Fired up by the death of one Muslim, a furious mob returned the next day
and invaded the marketplace. Rioters broke into Jewish homes and
strangled their occupants. Whether by accident or by design,  the French
police and military failed to  intervene.

By the time  the deputy Mayor, M Morinaud, appeared on the scene, 28
people had died – mostly women, old people and children. Damage to
property was put at 150 million Francs-Pointcare, affecting 1,777

In 1962, when Algeria gained its independence after a bloody war,  Jews
understood that they were not welcome.  The community of 160,000 Jews
fled – lock, stock and barrel – to France.

Now it looks like France gave these Jewish refugees just a temporary
respite from persecution.  For  the second time in a generation, Jews
are moving on.

Read article in full

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This website is dedicated to preserving the memory of the near-extinct Jewish communities, of the Middle East and North Africa, documenting the stories of the Jewish refugees and their current struggle for recognition and restitution.

Point of No Return

Jewish Refugees from Arab and Muslim Countries

One-stop blog on the Middle East's
forgotten Jewish refugees - updated daily.