Spain receives 6,000 enquiries about citizenship

 The synagogue of El Transito in Toledo, Spain

 An American member of Congress is among 6, 000 descendants of Jews forced out by the Spanish inquisition who have contacted the authorities about acquiring Spanish nationality. Report in The World:

Today in Spain there are only some 40,000 Jews. The head of the
Spanish Federation of Jewish Communities told Spanish TV that the new
offer of immediate citizenship for descendants had created a buzz in
Jewish communities around the world.

“I can tell you that in less than a month we have received about
6,000 inquiries, among which I would highlight one from an American
member of Congress,” he said.

A spokeswoman for the Federation could not say who that Congressman
was. But one American who has looked into the possibility of becoming
Spanish is Doreen Carvajal, a reporter with the New York Times in Paris.

Some years ago she learned she had Sephardic Jewish roots. She began
to investigate, even moved to Spain and wrote a book about her
experience, called “The Forgetting River.”

“My initial reaction was that it was a really thrilling moment,”
Carvajal said. “That it was an act of justice. They held this news
conference with top ministers to offer automatic citizenship to
descendents of all Sephardic Jews who left during inquisition. Point
blank done. 363 It was a romantic notion on my part. I told my husband, I
think I’m going to try and get the passport because it closes a circle.
It was very poetic,” Carvajal said.

But Carvajal says that when she contacted Spain’s Jewish Federation, she learned she didn’t qualify. Not yet anyway.

Part of Carvajal’s family was Sephardic Jew. But when they left
Spain for Costa Rica, they converted to Catholicism, at least
officially, out of fear of Spanish Inquisitors. The Inquisition hunted
down and persecuted Jews even in the far-off Spanish colonies.

So, Carvajal is technically the descendant of converts or, conversos.
She’s not a practising Jew herself. She says she was told she’d have
to convert to become Spanish.

“I felt like another it was act of being forced,” she said. “Here are
the these people, the descendants of the anousim, the forced ones, the
conversos, being told you have to do this, you have to be a certain
religion? So what happens if you’re a secular Jew? It was a bittersweet
moment for me when I realized there were a lot of clauses there and it
really wasn’t an automatic offer for everyone.”

Isaac Querub, the president of Spain’s Jewish Federation, did not
respond to multiple requests for interviews. Nor has Spain’s Justice
Ministry commented on why some descendants are excluded from the
citizenship offer.

Carvajal says she’s been left to wonder whether Spain just wants to
attract Jewish wealth, from known Sephardic enclaves that have survived
in place like Venezuela and Turkey.

Maria Josep Estanyol, an historian on Jews at the University of
Barcelona, says she’s not sure why Spain is splitting hairs now. But
she says it is well known that when Spain expelled the Jews in 1492 it
had disastrous effect on the economy.

Read article in full 

Now Muslims demand Spanish nationality


  • some corrections to my comment on Franco.
    During the civil war in Spain, he used Moorish/Moroccan troops against his own people. And they were effective and feared combat force. Recall the Spanish civil war song Ay Manuela with its line "Lucharon contra los moros" [they struggled against the Moors].
    During the civil war and WW2, Franco allowed German agents to propagandize among the Arabs in the Spanish zone of Morocco and later in Tangiers after Spain had occupied it. There were a number of Moroccans in the Spanish zone who were Arab nationalists and collaborators/agents of/ the Germans. One bore the curious name Abdel-Khalek [Abdel-Khaled?] Torres, which may indicate an ultimate Spanish origin of his family. Note again that leading Arab nationalists in the Spanish zone collaborated with the Nazis.

  • Sultana, of course Franco was helped to win the Spanish civil war by hitler and mussolini. He also sent troops [La Division Azul] to fight for the Germans on the Eastern Front. In 1940 [or approx] he sent his troops into Tangiers, up to then an international zone. Thus he ruled both Tangiers and the Spanish zone of Morocco, and in this capacity he encouraged Arab nationalism, especially against the French, and prevented Jewish youth from leaving to join the Allies.

    But the perfect opportunist that he was, when he saw the Germans losing the war [1943], he helped some Jews escape being sent to Auschwitz, and helped Jews in other ways.

    Just as interesting is that starting at the end of WW2, he took a big interest in helping Arab nationalists, selling weapons to the Palestinian Arabs for the 1948 war, sending observers to one of the first meetings of the Arab League [itself a British-sponsored institution], and giving sanctuary to German and Vichy French war criminals. Nasser once visited Franco in Madrid.

    This Spanish-Arab Friendship is little known today.

  • Please excuse my mistake concerning the film on the Spanish Civilwar, you will have corrected this mistake:
    It's of course FOR WHO THE BELLS TOLL with Gary Cooper and Ingrid Bergman.
    'ask not for who the bells toll for it may toll for you'

  • My thought on this matter are surely against that. i remember Franco as a partner of Nazism and if you want to think about it there was a civil war in Spain. A lot of people died. Ernest Hemingway wrote a FAREWELL TO ARMS and even participated in that war!
    Personally I would not want to mive in such a Catholic country. But that is my personal opinion!!!
    PS The actual Queen's mother, (Frederica not to name her) was a great friend of Hitler

  • Why would they want to? Spainish citizens freely admit they are some of the most antisemitic people in Europe.

  • The dictator,Francisco Franco [Franco is also a Jewish name], is credited with saving some Sefardic Jews from the Holocaust. But he did this only after he could see that the Germans were losing the war. I would not overrate his kindness towards Jews.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This website is dedicated to preserving the memory of the near-extinct Jewish communities, of the Middle East and North Africa, documenting the stories of the Jewish refugees and their current struggle for recognition and restitution.

Point of No Return

Jewish Refugees from Arab and Muslim Countries

One-stop blog on the Middle East's
forgotten Jewish refugees - updated daily.