The BBC admits forced exodus from Arab countries

 Inside the Al-Ghriba synagogue, Djerba, Tunisia

Thank you, Magdi Abdelhadi – you have finally said it – on the BBC: none of the 800,000 Jews who left Arab countries had wanted to leave – theirs was a forced exodus. In this piece distilled from the second part of his World Service radio programme ( listen to the first here) Abdelhadi interviews Tunisian Jews (with thanks: Robin):

Tunisia has a long Jewish
history – Jews were present in North Africa before the arrival of Islam
or Christianity. In good times they prospered and in hard times they
bore the brunt of discrimination, but now they are at risk of
extinction. Of 100,000 before the creation of Israel in 1948, only about
1,500 are left.

After the revolution that ousted President Zein al-Abidine
Ben Ali last year, there have been ominous signs. More than once,
hardline Salafists have staged demonstrations shouting “Death to the

This has alarmed many in Tunis’s tiny Jewish community.

“In around 15 years, we start to speak about the Jewish
community in the past tense,” says Jacob Lellouche, the only Jew who
tried to win a seat on the assembly drafting Tunisia’s new constitution.
(He didn’t succeed.)

But while he is gloomy about the future he is also a dreamer,
and the centrepiece of his dream is a small villa in the seaside suburb
of La Goulette.

The white two-storey colonial era house has a blue metal gate
that carries a big sign – Mamie Lily Restaurant. Lily is his
85-year-old mother and the master chef.

“She is the heart and the memory of Jewish cooking in Tunisia,” says the chain-smoking Lellouche.

He left Tunisia in 1978 to study marketing and economics in
France but decided to return to his roots in 1996, to live with his
mother and to found “the last kosher restaurant in Tunisia”.

“I want to invite my clients to a cultural trip… to an old Jewish house with a Jewish mamie in the kitchen,” he says.

“When she speaks to the clients it’s like a Jewish mother
speaking to her kids. ‘Don’t put salt on this, it’s not good… No, it’s
enough, you don’t have to eat this or that,'” he adds, letting out a
croaky laugh.

Lellouche says there are traces of Jewish culture everywhere
in Tunisia, in music, handicraft, literature and names. He hopes that
all Tunisians will one day become aware of their common culture and
history regardless of their religion.

In the kitchen, Lily sits on a low stool. In front of her is a big bowl of okra – the dish of the day.

She has sparkling brown eyes, a deep voice and an
unmistakable air of authority. Like most Tunisians she mixes Arabic with
French freely. How is life in Tunisia today, I ask?

“On etait mieux avec Ben Ali,” she says. (“Things were better under Ben Ali.”)

Why was it better before?

“On a peur de Salafis,” is her short answer. (“We are afraid of the Salafists.”)

The emergence of the hardline Salafists – a brand of Islam
practised in Saudi Arabia which adopts a literalist interpretation of
the Koran and preaches strict separation of the sexes, and rejection of
Western lifestyles – has taken everyone by surprise.

By all accounts they are a tiny minority, but they are vocal, active and prone to violence.

Lellouche foresees the end of Jewish life in Tunis – though he thinks it will survive on the island of Djerba in the south.

A few blocks away from Mamie’s restaurant is Beit Mordechai, a
small modern synagogue that is difficult to distinguish from the other
residential houses on the narrow street.

When I arrive during the evening
prayer the atmosphere is warm and informal. The grown-ups are praying,
the kids are running around. It’s a small congregation and someone has
prepared a cake to share after the prayer. 

Ellie Attoun, a 39-year-old businessman, is originally from
the south, but during the Israeli invasion of Lebanon in 1982 there were
demonstrations against the Jews there and his family relocated to the

He says he was optimistic when the revolution broke out last year, the first episode of the Arab Spring.

“At the beginning we wanted to see
Tunisia open, modern with all what we see in Western Europe. We wanted
to look like the modern world. But unfortunately, a few weeks and months
after there’s a small part of Tunisian people [who] are against the
modernism that the big majority of Tunisian people want.”

One of his concerns now is that “we don’t see a real will from the government to act against those people”.

I put those concerns to the leader of the Nahda movement,
Rachid Ghannouchi, the mainstream Islamist party that leads the current
coalition government.

Ghannouchi says Tunisian law prohibits incitement to violence
against any group, and that he has reassured representatives of the
Jewish community that those responsible will be tried.

No-one has been tried yet, he concedes, but it took America 10 years to hunt down Bin Laden, he points out.

Nahda’s attitude is regarded by some Tunisians as a form of
double-speak. They accuse it of paying lip service to democratic values –
freedom of expression, equal rights to all citizens, rule of law –
while in reality having much in common with the ultra-conservative

On Djerba, the heartland of Judaism in Tunisia and home to
one of oldest synagogues in the world, El-Ghriba, the Salafists do not
seem to have a presence, but the news of their threats has reached the
small Jewish community.

A Jewish man, a 53-year-old father of six, says he has seen
“Death to the Jews” scrawled on the wall. He writes over it “Death to
those who want death to the Jews,” he tells me.

He lived in the West for nine years, but he came back, he says, because he loves his traditional lifestyle.

I ask him what he feels about the
future. He say it is all in the hands of the government – if it creates
safety and stability then the Jews have nothing to fear. 

None of those I asked said they wanted to leave Tunisia or have made such plans.

But none of the 800,000 or so Jews who used to live in Arab societies before 1948 had wanted to leave.

In most cases theirs was a forced departure. The majority
went to Israel, while some 200,000 fled to the West. Now, it is thought
there are less than 20,000 left.

Read article in full


  • As to Avi Shushan who was quoted about the Likud a few days ago, there is room for complaints, but on the Likud candidte list, he is wrong. The Likud is having primaries later this year where it will choose its candidate list. Among the Likud MKs are Danny Danon –considered an up and coming party leader– Miri Regev, Gila Gamliel, MK Shama-Cohen, Tsipi Hotobely –also a leader [but she's Georgian, thus maybe not Mizrahi for some because of Russian influence on Georgia]. These MKs are Mizrahim. And we have not yet had primaries.

    10:24 AM, October 26, 2012

  • The BBC slant is "These are good pathetic sad worried Jews who aren't those evil blood drinking Zionists. We should let them live a while more."

  • The correct word that was shouted to the new Gazawi president was
    "Edbah el Yehud"
    in other words slaughter the Jews
    Why are we Jews so attached to our Arab country? Simply because we
    were born there and lived happily up to a certain period of time. But
    sadly there no longer is any place for Jews in Arab countries.It is
    difficult to swallow!
    Sultana Latifa


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This website is dedicated to preserving the memory of the near-extinct Jewish communities, of the Middle East and North Africa, documenting the stories of the Jewish refugees and their current struggle for recognition and restitution.

Point of No Return

Jewish Refugees from Arab and Muslim Countries

One-stop blog on the Middle East's
forgotten Jewish refugees - updated daily.