Jewish refugees debate on Harry’s Place

If you hurry you might still be in time to catch a debate on Harry’s Place where the final comments of the thread deal with Jewish refugees from Arab countries. (With thanks: Avril)


  • The comments may be closed on Harry’s Place, but here on PONR, we appreciate your knowledge and erudition, Eliyahu!

  • I wanted to comment on the post and thread on Harry’s Place. But apparently comments were closed there and I could not do so. I hope that my remarks below are helpful.
    – – – – – –
    The universities in the United Kingdom have a grand tradition going back to the Middle Ages. But the ignorant and dishonest divestment resolution passed by the SU at LSE demonstrates considerable deterioration in intellectual capacity and integrity. As said above, there are too many lies & distortions to answer all of them. However, let’s try to correct a few of them.
    1) lies regarding UN resolutions. All General Assembly political resolutions are only recommendations by definition [Arts. 10-12 of the UN charter]. This applies to GA res. 194 which is not law, does not fix “rights,” but merely recommends. Indeed, 194 imposes conditions on Arabs who want to “return.”
    2) the lie regarding Geneva IV which does not forbid people from freely moving across an armistice line, not the same as “transfer.”
    3) the legal status of the Land of Israel as a whole. The San Remo Conference [1920] juridically erected the Jewish National Home in international law. The League of Nations, recognizing the Jewish link to the land, endorsed the JNH principle. The UN charter [Art. 80] confirmed the Jewish right to the Land of Israel. By the way, Arab expert witnesses testifying on behalf of the Palestinian Arabs at the 1946 Anglo-American Committee of Inquiry on Palestine denied that there was ever such a place as “palestine” in history. Now, they eagerly use the terms “palestine” and “palestinian people” since that usage is expedient nowadays.
    4) the SU ignores the Arab & palestinian Arab oppression of Jews in history for more than a thousand years.
    5) the SU ignores Arab & Palestinian Arab collaboration in the Holocaust, especially in the person of Haj Amin el-Husseini [Husayni]. During the Holocaust, Husseini broadcast to the Arab lands over Radio Berlin. Among other things, he called on Arabs to: Kill Jews wherever you find them [see Lukasz Hirszowicz, The Third Reich & the Arab East]. Arabs also contributed to the Holocaust by pressuring the UK govt to severely limit Jewish immigration to the Jewish National Home when the Jews most needed a home [1939 White Paper]
    5) In the 1947-1949 Israeli War of Independence, Arabs started to attack Jewish civilians within hours after the UN GA partition recommendation. Jews were driven out of their homes in south Tel Aviv and the Shim`on haTsadiq neighborhood of East Jerusalem in December 1947. On the other hand, Arabs were told to flee their homes by Arabs govts & armies, and by Husseini’s Arab Higher Committee. Bataween is right on that point.
    6) apartheid in a religious form exists in Saudi Arabia, Egypt, and other Arab states, as mentioned above.
    7) Since Arabs oppressed, persecuted, humiliated and exploited Jews in the Jewish homeland over the centuries since the Arab conquest [7th century], it would be just for Israel to apply “affirmative action” {corrective discrimination] in favor of Jews.
    8) the SU falsely insinuates that Israel prevents Muslim worship at the Al-Aqsa Mosque and the Churhc of the Holy Sepulcher. But SU does not mention that Jews are prevented from praying on the Temple Mount, a Jewish holy place usurped by Arab/Muslim conquerors.
    9) there is much real estate in Gaza and the “West Bank” owned by Jews, such as the Kfar Darom land in the Gaza Strip which was populated by Jews before 1948 (cf. Ignaz & Alcuin).
    10) the references to Tutu, Carter, Dugard & Ben Yair prove nought since these are all bigoted politicians who take “leftist” positions out of politically correct Judeophobia.
    Really, the LSESU is a disgrace to a country with a respected scholarly tradition.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This website is dedicated to preserving the memory of the near-extinct Jewish communities, of the Middle East and North Africa, documenting the stories of the Jewish refugees and their current struggle for recognition and restitution.

Point of No Return

Jewish Refugees from Arab and Muslim Countries

One-stop blog on the Middle East's
forgotten Jewish refugees - updated daily.