Torn loyalties of Israel’s Iranian Jews

Iranian Jews in Israel are like a child torn between two divorcing parents, the BBC reports (with thanks: Albert)

For the population of Iranian Jews in Israel, some of whom still have relatives in Iran, it (Iran’s nuclear programme) is a matter of deep concern.

Every day the Voice of Israel radio broadcasts to Iran in Farsi. Twice a week Menashe Amir, a Persian Israeli, hosts a rather unexpected talk show. The callers are all from Iran and the vast majority are Muslim.

The show attracts two to six million listeners everyday from a country where the Jewish community is just 20,000 strong.

“I would say if 10 people are calling us from Iran, only one is talking about destroying Israel or death to Israel,” said Mr Amir.

The Iranian callers cannot ring Israel directly. They have to phone a number in Germany which is patched through to the Jerusalem studio. Mr Amir is worried about the current state of affairs in Iran. “I am an Iranian and I am an Israeli. This is a bad period but I hope it will be very short,” he said.

But he says the ancient links between Jews and Iranians, which date back to the time of the Persian emperor Cyrus the Great, will not be broken so easily. On a busy shopping street in Jerusalem is a line of several shoe shops all run by Persian Jews, a sign of the thriving community here. Many of these families came to Israel after the Iranian revolution in 1979. But that did not put an end to their connections with Iran. While Persian Israelis are reluctant to admit visiting Iran, it is possible to travel there by getting permission from the Iranian embassy in Turkey. But these days, things have become more difficult. There is growing alarm that Iran’s atomic energy programme could be a cover for nuclear weapons. For many Israelis that is an unacceptable danger, which has to be stopped.

The Ochlim Bashuq Persian cafe in the Mehane Yehuda market in Jerusalem is a nostalgic place for Iranian Israelis such as the Iran analyst Meir Javedanfar, who was born in Tehran. On the walls there are old bank notes with pictures of the Shah, and battered metal pots of ashe torsh, a Persian Jewish version of chicken soup bubble away on the hobs. “To me the current conflict is like parents going through a divorce. Who do you like more, your mother or your father? You like both of them,” said Mr Javedanfar.

Mr Javedanfar doesn’t want war between the two countries. But he says that nightmare scenario is becoming more realistic. “Israel is going to have to take a decision of being obliterated by Iran or it is going to have to attack Iran and put the lives of 20,000 Jews there at risk,” he said.

Read article in full

One Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This website is dedicated to preserving the memory of the near-extinct Jewish communities, of the Middle East and North Africa, documenting the stories of the Jewish refugees and their current struggle for recognition and restitution.

Point of No Return

Jewish Refugees from Arab and Muslim Countries

One-stop blog on the Middle East's
forgotten Jewish refugees - updated daily.